Even though RevengeShipping is a Crack Pairing, it is still fascinating to find similarities or proof between the two shipped characters.
"Definition of Proof: Proof is any factual evidence that helps to establish the truth of something; "if you have any proof for what you say, now is the time to produce it."
- Scourge and Ashpaw were both alive in The Darkest Hour, meaning if they wanted to, they could've met then.
- Ashpaw was noted to have been there when Tigerstar introduced BloodClan.
- Ashfur and Scourge both hated somebody in the Tigerstar family line, giving them a possible strong connection.
- Ashfur could have tried to kill Firestar for revenge for killing Scourge.
- Both were innocent cats until a she-cat messed with them.
- Both have a strong hatred for Tigerstar.
- Both have blue eyes.
- Both have some kind of relation to Cloudtail.
- Both were killed by someone in Firestar's family.
- Scourge and Squirrelflight both had similar personalities, and are the only two cats with one white paw. Therefore it makes sense that Ashfur would fall in love with Squirrelflight, seeing her as a replacement for Scourge.
There are many theories on how they could've met, if they ever did. (Which we all know they didn't.) Here are some of them.
This theory is that in Rising Storm Cloudpaw gets taken by two-legs. Ashfur finds out and is very frantic and frightened for his friend. So the theory is that he runs off to try and find him and gets captured by BloodClan cats where he meets Scourge.
The Darkest TheoryEdit
This theory is that they meet sometime between The Rising Storm and The Darkest Hour. This pairing is the most popular amoung RevengeShippers. Some RevengeShippers think that Ashpaw took down Bone, and uttered a victorious cry, because he would have less competition for Scourge. This theory also follows the series- meaning Scourge dies at the end of The Darkest Hour.
Sitavara on DeviantArt, created a comic that followed this idea.
Broken Hearted TheoryEdit
This theory is that after Ashfur got rejected, Scourge finds him and they meet then. Scourge is then the one who gives him ideas on how to get revenge on Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw.